Owning a $500,000 house at 7.18% costs $3,793 a month against $2,600 to rent, and the $1,193 difference does not make renting the winner: buying pulls ahead in month 166, which is 13 years and 10 months. At $2,200 of rent the same house never catches up.
Both paths start with the same cash and end on the same date. Selling costs are taken out of the house before the loan is repaid. Rent and home prices grow every month rather than once a year. The break-even month is the first month the owner's net proceeds exceed the renter's account balance, so a result of Never means renting stays ahead for the whole loan term at these inputs.
A $3,793 payment against $2,600 of rent looks like a $1,193 penalty for owning, and part of that penalty is not a cost at all: principal leaves the borrower's pocket and arrives in the borrower's equity. Counting only the outflow overstates what owning costs and ignores what is left when the house is sold, which is the only moment the two paths can be compared fairly.
The renter's side is the one people leave out. The down payment is not free money: invested at 5% it becomes $162,889 in ten years, and the $1,193 a month the owner pays above the rent is money the renter still has, which is why the renter's account reaches $289,109 by year ten while the owner's net proceeds are $262,846.
The comparison therefore answers a narrower question than whether owning is better. It asks what each path leaves behind on the day the house is sold, with the same cash and the same assumptions on both sides. A buyer who never sells has a different answer, and that case sits outside this page.
Ten years in, the house is worth $646,314, the loan still owes $344,689, and selling takes $38,779, so the owner walks away with $262,846. The renter who invested the $100,000 down payment and every monthly difference has $289,109. Renting is ahead by $26,263 at the ten-year mark, which is not the result the monthly payments suggest.
| Year | House value | Owner's net after selling | Renter's account | Buying minus renting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | $568,469 | $156,885 | $197,193 | -$38,969 |
| 10 | $646,314 | $262,846 | $289,109 | -$26,263 |
| 15 | $734,819 | $391,925 | $377,714 | +$19,234 |
| 20 | $835,444 | $553,020 | $447,474 | +$112,998 |
| 30 | $1,079,918 | $1,015,123 | $489,415 | +$539,234 |
The gap narrows because the renter's monthly advantage shrinks while the owner's equity compounds. Rent rises 3% a year against a fixed payment, so the $1,193 difference is gone by the time rent and ownership cost meet, and after that the renter is drawing the difference out of the account instead of adding to it. At year 5 renting leads by $38,969; at year 15 owning leads by $19,234. The crossing sits in month 166.
The shape matters more than the exact month. Buying is behind for a decade and then pulls away quickly, which means the risk of buying short is not a small loss but the whole transaction cost; the reward for staying is not linear either. A buyer who sells at year 7 gets the worst of both, and the table shows why: the house has gained value, the loan has barely amortised, and the selling cost takes 6% of a larger number than it would have at purchase.
Change only the rent and the answer moves further than any other single input. At $2,200 a month the same house does not pull ahead within 30 years — there is no crossing point at all, and renting finishes ten years $100,736 ahead. At $3,000 the crossing arrives in month 78, six and a half years.
| Rent a month, dollars | Months to break even | Buying minus renting at year 10 |
|---|---|---|
| 2,200 | 340 | -$97,738 |
| 2,600 | 166 | -$26,263 |
| 3,000 | 78 | +$45,212 |
This is why rent-versus-buy arguments that start with price forecasts are hard to settle: the same house is a six-year decision in one market and a never decision in another, and the difference is what the market charges to rent it. A buyer who is choosing between two cities is choosing between two answers, and the rent is the number that carries the information.
The rent that matters is not the rent paid now but the rent that would be paid for the same house. Comparing a $2,600 apartment with a $500,000 house only works if the apartment is genuinely comparable in size, location and condition; a cheaper rental that is smaller makes owning look better than it is, and an expensive rental in a better school district does the opposite.
Selling costs $38,779 on the ten-year sale, and that money leaves with the house whether the market was good or bad. Set the selling cost to zero and the crossing moves from month 166 to month 97, so more than half the wait is the cost of getting out rather than the cost of getting in.
| Home price growth a year | Months to break even | Buying minus renting at year 10 |
|---|---|---|
| 2.0% | 227 | -$60,871 |
| 2.6% | 166 | -$26,263 |
| 4.0% | 64 | +$61,917 |
Price growth and selling cost are the same arithmetic seen from two sides. A house growing 2.6% a year needs more than two years of gains to cover a 6% exit, which is why the first years of a mortgage are the most expensive ones to abandon; growth of 4% cuts the wait to month 64 because each year of ownership now pays the exit cost faster.
The second lever is the return on money that is not spent on the house. At 5% the crossing is month 166; at 7% it never arrives within 30 years and renting finishes $39,810 ahead. A reader who would genuinely invest the difference at 7% is not comparing the same two things this page compares at 5%, and the page is only useful if that input reflects what they would actually do with the money.
Ownership costs are one number here, 2.6% of value a year, covering property tax, homeowners insurance and maintenance together. Those three vary more by state and by house than any other input on the page, so the figure is a placeholder the reader should replace rather than a national average.
Mortgage interest is not deducted from income. After the 2017 change to the standard deduction most owners take the standard deduction rather than itemising, so a deduction model would overstate the tax benefit for the typical buyer here, and a page that quietly assumed itemising would flatter owning by an amount most readers never receive.
One house, one sale, no reinvestment. The owner sells at the end of the horizon and does not buy again; a move-up purchase resets both the selling cost and the mortgage, which is a different calculation with a different horizon. Maintenance is treated as a smooth percentage rather than as a roof in year twelve, which understates the variance around the answer without changing its direction.
What the page will not say is that 13 years is the right answer for anyone in particular. It is the answer at 7.24%, 2.6% growth, 6% selling costs and 5% on the alternative, and each of those four numbers moves the crossing by years. A reader who replaces them gets a different number, and that number — not this one — is the one worth acting on.
On the defaults here, month 166, or 13 years and 10 months. That is not a general rule: at $3,000 of rent the same house crosses in month 78, and at $2,200 it never crosses within 30 years. The answer is set by the rent-to-price ratio, the cost of selling and the return available on the money not spent on a house.
Because the renter keeps the down payment invested and adds the monthly difference to it, while the owner's equity has to absorb a 6% selling cost before it counts. At year ten the owner's net proceeds are $262,846 against the renter's $289,109. The owner catches up afterwards because rent keeps rising while the mortgage payment does not.
Not as a cost, but as capital that is tied up. The page treats the down payment as money that could have been invested at the alternative return, so it appears on the renter's side as a growing balance. Leaving it out entirely is the most common way a rent-versus-buy comparison flatters buying.
Whatever you would actually earn on it, net of fees and taxes. The page defaults to 5% and the result is sensitive: at 7% the owner is still $39,810 behind after 30 years on these inputs. Using a stock-market average you would not have stayed invested for is the easiest way to get a wrong answer in either direction.
No. Most homeowners now take the standard deduction instead of itemising, so a deduction model would credit the typical buyer with a benefit they do not receive. For a high earner with large charitable deductions and a jumbo loan the deduction can matter, and this page would then understate the case for buying.
It is paid once, in full, at the end, and it is charged on the sale price rather than on the gain. At 6% on a $646,314 house that is $38,779, which the first years of appreciation have to cover before ownership shows a profit. Removing it moves the crossing from month 166 to month 97.
Rent vs Buy Break-Even Calculator lists each external figure it uses once, with the publisher that issues it and the date it was retrieved. The calculator takes these as its defaults, so any of them can be replaced with a number of your own; a figure that is not in the list is one this page did not take from anywhere.
| Figure | Value | Published by | Retrieved |
|---|---|---|---|
| 30-year fixed mortgage national average | 7.18% | Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey (PMMS) | 2026-11-10 |
| Twelve-month change in U.S. house prices | 2.6% | Federal Housing Finance Agency, U.S. House Price Index release for September 2026 | 2026-10-10 |
Values are the ones this page is built with, not a live feed. Where a figure is revised on a schedule, the retrieval date above is when it was read, and the next scheduled refresh is shown at the top of the page.
Related calculatorsTrue monthly payment (PITI + HOA) · Down payment calculator · How long you pay PMI · Closing costs, both ends of the sale
Cluster us/mortgage · Unit us-mortgage-rent-vs-buy-horizon · Engine rent-vs-buy / horizon · Method: Both paths start with the same cash and end on the same date. The owner puts the down payment into the house, pays principal and interest monthly plus an annual ownership cost of 2.6% of value for property tax, insurance and maintenance, and sells at the end of the horizon for the appreciated value less a 6% selling cost, repaying the remaining balance. The renter invests the down payment at 5% a year and adds the monthly difference between owning and renting to that account, or draws from it when rent is the larger number; rent rises 3% a year and the house 2.6%. Every month is computed at month end on both sides, and the break-even month is the first month in which the owner's net proceeds exceed the renter's account balance. No tax deduction is modelled.