An appraisal $30,000 under a $500,000 contract leaves the $400,000 loan at 85.1% of value instead of 80%, which starts $193.33 a month of mortgage insurance and keeps it running for 83 months. The gap costs $46,047, not $30,000. Enter your own price, appraisal and down payment below.
Loan-to-value is measured against the lower of contract price and appraised value. The insurance rate is a flat annual percentage on the loan, held constant for the life of the premium; real quotes step up as loan-to-value rises, so the monthly figure here is arithmetic on the rate you enter, not a quote. When the appraisal comes in at or above the contract price the gap is zero and no insurance appears.
Loan-to-value divides the loan by the value the lender recognises, and lenders recognise the lower of the contract price and the appraisal. A $500,000 contract appraised at $470,000 keeps a $400,000 loan at 85.1% of value, even though the buyer's 20% down payment bought exactly 80% of the contract price the week before.
The borrower cannot close the gap by borrowing it. The lender will not lend against value the appraiser did not find, so the $30,000 has to come from the buyer's own funds, and the loan stays at $400,000. That is why the cash requirement rises and the loan does not fall: the deal got more expensive without getting smaller.
| Cover the gap in cash | Renegotiate to the appraisal | |
|---|---|---|
| Cash into the purchase | $130,000 | $94,000 |
| Loan amount | $400,000 | $376,000 |
| Loan-to-value | 85.1% | 80.0% |
| Mortgage insurance | $193.33 | none |
| Payment with insurance | $2,903.07 | $2,547.15 |
The two columns buy the same house at two different prices, which is the honest way to read them. Covering the gap accepts the contract price and pays for it in cash and insurance; renegotiating accepts the appraised value and pays for it by asking the seller to move. Everything else in the deal is held constant, so the differences between the columns are differences between those two decisions.
Thirty thousand dollars is the number that appears on the closing disclosure, and it is not what the gap costs. The same appraisal pushes the loan over 80% of value, which starts mortgage insurance at $193.33 a month, and the premium runs 83 months before the balance reaches 78% of the appraised value. That is $16,047 which a $500,000 valuation would never have charged.
Add the two and the gap costs $46,047 — a 53% surcharge on the cash figure, paid in two places that are a month apart in the file and rarely added together. The cash is due at closing; the insurance arrives with the first statement and is easy to treat as part of the mortgage rather than as a consequence of the appraisal.
The surcharge is entirely a threshold effect rather than a slope. At $500,000 the loan is at exactly 80% and no premium applies at any point in the schedule. At $470,000 the same loan is at 85.1% and the premium applies from the first month. A $30,000 move in the valuation therefore changes the insurance bill by the full $16,047, not by a proportional slice of it, which is why the gap has no comfortable middle.
A $30,000 price reduction does what $30,000 of extra cash does, and it does it without the insurance. At $470,000 the 20% down payment is $94,000, the loan is $376,000, and loan-to-value sits exactly on 80% — no premium, no cancellation date to wait for, $355.92 a month less to pay. The buyer also keeps $36,000 more in the bank, because the cash requirement fell along with the price.
That comparison is not a suggestion that sellers agree to it. An appraisal below contract gives the buyer a documented reason to reopen the price, and in a soft market it is often enough; in a competitive one the seller may refuse and the buyer is back to the cash gap. The page prices both outcomes because only one of them is inside the buyer's control.
There is a third route worth naming so it is not mistaken for a fourth kind of arithmetic. The buyer can close with a first loan at 80% of the appraisal and a second loan or a family loan for the remainder of the cash. That keeps the first loan free of insurance, but the second is priced as a second lien, usually at a higher rate and a shorter term, so the monthly saving on the first is partly handed back on the second.
Mortgage insurance ends on a schedule measured against the property's original value, and once an appraisal comes in low that appraisal is the value in the schedule. The same $400,000 balance that carried no premium at a $500,000 valuation now has to amortise to $366,600 — 78% of $470,000 — before the automatic termination applies. At $2,710 a month the first years barely move the balance, so that distance is measured in years rather than months.
The borrower can also ask for cancellation at 80% of value, and that request can be made earlier than the automatic date, but it requires a good payment record and the lender may require evidence that the value has not fallen. Both of those are harder to supply right after an appraisal came in under contract, which is the small irony of this particular gap: the document that started the premium is also the one that makes it harder to argue the premium away.
| Appraised value | Cash gap | Loan-to-value | Insurance a month | Months of insurance | Insurance paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $470,000 | $30,000 | 85.1% | $193.33 | 83 | $16,047 |
| $450,000 | $50,000 | 88.9% | $193.33 | 111 | $21,267 |
| $430,000 | $70,000 | 93.0% | $193.33 | 135 | $25,907 |
The monthly figure holds steady down that table only because the rate is held steady, which is a choice the next section defends. What moves is the duration: each further $20,000 off the appraisal adds roughly 25 months of premium, because the 78% target falls faster than the balance can chase it.
The insurance rate is a flat percentage of the loan, entered by the reader, rather than a table of tiers. Real premiums step up with loan-to-value and with weaker credit, so a borrower at 93% pays more per dollar borrowed than one at 85%. Modelling that would mean publishing a rate card for a lender nobody has called, so the page applies one rate and says so — the reader who has an actual quote can type it in and get the arithmetic for their own number.
Property tax, homeowners insurance and HOA dues are left out because they scale with the price and the model does not need a second value assumption to answer the question asked. Closing costs are left out for the same reason: they are paid on either path and the gap does not change the fee schedule enough to matter at this scale.
Two things the page cannot price are worth flagging before anyone relies on it. Some states and some loan programs treat appraisal shortfalls differently, and a few require the buyer's own attorney to review the gap disclosure before closing. And an appraisal is not final: a reconsideration of value can be requested with comparable sales the appraiser did not consider, and if it succeeds the entire chain above disappears. That request costs nothing but time, which makes it the first thing to try.
What the page will not say is that a low appraisal means the house is overpriced. It means one appraiser, working for the lender, found fewer or lower comparable sales than the contract reflected. In a fast market that happens routinely and the contract still closes. The number worth acting on is not the appraisal, it is the $46,047 — and half of it is only visible if someone adds the insurance back in.
The buyer, in cash, unless the seller agrees to reduce the price. The lender will lend against the appraised value, not the contract price, so the difference between the two has to come from the buyer's own funds. Some loan programs and some seller concessions can soften it, but the default answer is that the buyer covers it at closing.
Only when it pushes the loan above 80% of the appraised value. On this page a 20% down payment at $500,000 sits exactly on the line; the same loan against a $470,000 appraisal sits at 85.1% and the premium starts. A buyer who put down 30% would be at 77.8% after the same appraisal and would still avoid it, which is why the down payment percentage, not the gap, decides whether the insurance appears.
Until the balance reaches 78% of the appraised value on the original amortisation schedule. On the default numbers that is 83 months, and it is longer than it would have been at the contract price because the target ($366,600) is lower than the one the original plan implied ($390,000). Paying the loan down faster shortens the request date but not the automatic termination date.
Not from the same lender as part of the first mortgage, because the first loan is already at the maximum the appraised value supports. A second loan, a family loan or a down payment assistance program can supply the cash, but a second lien is priced higher and carries a shorter term, so it moves the cost rather than removing it.
Then the gap is cash, and the only remaining levers are the appraisal itself and the loan structure. A reconsideration of value with better comparables is free to request and occasionally moves the number. Failing that, the buyer either covers the gap, adds a second loan, or walks — and walking is a real option when the gap plus the insurance exceeds what the house is worth to them.
At these inputs, yes, and the second number is the one that gets forgotten. The $30,000 is due at closing and visible. The $16,047 is a monthly premium created by the same appraisal, and it is only visible if the insurance is added back to the cash. The two are paid months apart to different parties, which is why they are rarely summed.
Appraisal Gap Calculator lists each external figure it uses once, with the publisher that issues it and the date it was retrieved. The calculator takes these as its defaults, so any of them can be replaced with a number of your own; a figure that is not in the list is one this page did not take from anywhere.
| Figure | Value | Published by | Retrieved |
|---|---|---|---|
| 30-year fixed mortgage national average | 7.18% | Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey (PMMS) | 2026-11-10 |
| Annual PMI premium, low end of the published range | 0.58% | Fannie Mae, What to Know About Private Mortgage Insurance | 2026-10-09 |
Values are the ones this page is built with, not a live feed. Where a figure is revised on a schedule, the retrieval date above is when it was read, and the next scheduled refresh is shown at the top of the page.
Related calculatorsDown payment calculator · How long you pay PMI · Just over the conforming limit · True monthly payment (PITI + HOA)
Cluster us/mortgage · Unit us-mortgage-appraisal-gap · Engine amortizing-loan / appraisal-gap · Method: The loan is sized from the contract price and the down payment percentage, because the buyer's cash does not change when the appraisal does. Loan-to-value is measured against the lower of contract price and appraised value, which is the value the lender recognises. Mortgage insurance is a flat annual rate on the loan, applied monthly, and it runs from closing until the amortising balance reaches 78% of that same lower value. The renegotiated path re-prices the purchase at the appraised value with the same down payment percentage, so its loan and payment are recomputed rather than adjusted.