$
%
months
$
$
%
$
months
$25,017what the best path is worth over doing nothing, at your horizon
Required payment today
$2,279.65
Required payment after a recast
$1,923.46
Required payment after the refinance alone
$1,968.21
Required payment after refinancing and applying the cash
$1,660.68
Recast, against doing nothing
+$17,194
Refinance alone, against doing nothing
+$9,902
Refinance and apply, against doing nothing
+$25,017
Your cash as a share of the balance
15.63%

Assumptions this tool makes. The loan is fixed-rate and amortised in equal monthly payments; the payment shown is principal and interest only, so it excludes property tax, homeowners insurance and mortgage insurance. The refinance is modelled as a new 30-year loan at the rate entered, with closing costs paid in cash at closing. The recast is modelled as a re-amortisation of the reduced balance over the months already remaining, with the fee paid in cash. Every path is scored as cash in hand minus balance owed at the end of the horizon, which is the position if the balance is settled at that point. The page does not model points paid to buy the refinance rate down, nor any investment return on the cash that a lower payment frees up.

Calculator by FigureDeck — free, no sign-up, and every figure is sourced.

The same cash on five paths

PathRequired paymentBalance at the horizonCash in handBetter than doing nothing
Do nothing$2,279.65$294,859-$86,779$0
Recast: same rate, same term$1,923.46$248,787-$115,657+$17,194
Lump sum, keep the payment$2,279.65$223,127-$136,779+$21,732
Refinance at the new rate$1,968.21$298,644-$73,093+$9,902
Refinance and apply the lump sum$1,660.68$251,980-$104,641+$25,017

Gain over doing nothing, by how long you keep the loan

HorizonRecastApply the cash, keep the paymentRefinance aloneRefinance and apply
1 year+$3,348+$3,743-$1,836+$1,268
2 years+$6,895+$7,765+$1,246+$7,415
3 years+$10,388+$12,089+$4,236+$13,431
5 years+$17,194+$21,732+$9,902+$25,017
7 years+$23,728+$32,872+$15,074+$35,916
10 years+$32,930+$52,909+$21,673+$50,685